spacer

Three Way News

Your Source. For everything. Really.

Contributors

Current Poll

Best comic strip?

  • Bloom County
  • Boondocks
  • Calvin and Hobbes
  • Dilbert
  • Doonesbury
  • Far Side
  • Foxtrot
  • Get Fuzzy
  • Life in Hell
  • Peanuts
  • Pearls Before Swine
  • Pogo
  • Zippy the Pinhead
  
Free polls from Pollhost.com

Recurring features

Hammer's Favorites

Jambo's Favories

Wednesday, August 01, 2007

Nominations for the new A.G.

Posted by: Hammer / 10:00 AM

Recent polls suggest 70% of Americans support the investigation of U.S. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales and 40% support impeachment. We need continuity in this vital law enforcement post. Joe Conason expands on the argument:

While politicians of both parties have repeatedly denounced Alberto Gonzales for public mendacity and abuse of office, a few of them finally have stepped up to do what must be done. On July 31, Representative Jay Inslee (D-WA) and, as of this writing, at least five colleagues—four of them former prosecutors—filed a resolution directing the House Judiciary Committee to open an impeachment investigation of the attorney general.

The logic of Mr. Inslee’s initiative is inescapable to anyone who has been listening to the Congressional complaints about Mr. Gonzales. If legislators from both branches and both parties believe that the attorney general has repeatedly deceived Congress and the public about matters of importance, if they believe that he has committed those deceptions under oath in the Capitol and if they believe that the president will do nothing to remedy these wrongs, then impeachment can be their only serious response.

I nominate Little Sister Hammer for the job. Firstly, she is on record expressing her affection for liars:

I like Jack Sparrow because he lies.

Secondly, she would be a brilliant replacement for Fredo's testimony before Congress:

I am the biggest in the class. Well, I'm not the biggest. Jack's the biggest. But I am the biggest.

I'd like to see Charles Schumer swim through that 5-year-old logic.

Labels: ,

0 comments

Sunday, July 29, 2007

Gonzales: data mining is the dodge

Posted by: Hammer / 8:57 AM

Looks like the part of the so-called Terrorist Surveillance Program which was excised due to disagreement involved some form of broad-based data mining. The New York Times and Washington Post have dueling stories.

Terrorist Surveillance Program, right? Who, in fact, was surveilled? Just about all of us:

The warrantless surveillance program, which was authorized by presidential order after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, was first revealed publicly by the Times in December 2005. Bush confirmed aspects of the program at that time, defining it as monitoring communications between the United States and overseas in which one party was suspected of ties to al-Qaeda.

The Washington Post reported in February 2006 that the NSA targets were identified through data mining efforts and that thousands of Americans had been monitored. USA Today later reported that the government had the help of telecommunications companies in collecting millions of phone records.

So the NSA went through our phone calls and emails, without a warrant. From that data they identified suspects. Then they monitored those suspects, without a warrant. Even when the communications involved U.S. citizens living in the United States. Still, no warrants.

Important note -- it is not clear from either news report how deeply the NSA looked into the communications. It is clear that the NSA reviewed the logs of communications. That's the evidence that the communications took place. It is not clear whether the NSA looked at the content of the communications.

Two points here. First, I'm not impressed with the distinction that the NSA was intruding on our right to freely associate rather than our right to freely speak. Second, given the objections to the program, I suspect the NSA was listening in to at least some of these communications.

Labels: , ,

0 comments

Saturday, July 28, 2007

Alberto Gonzales: I understand the deception

Posted by: Hammer / 6:46 AM

It came to me like a flash. It's a deception of enormous quality. Perfect efficiency. A bureaucratic shuffling of meaning almost on par with the famous Catch-22.

Al Gonzales denied there was any dispute over the Terrorist Surveillance Program. Then James Comey came along and asserted there was a huge row over renewing the NSA's spying program. Robert Mueller and John Negroponte sided with Comey.

So how does Gonzales look Senators in the face and lie?

Beautifully.

It takes the breath away. The Terrorist Surveillance Program, to Gonzales, is simply whatever warrantless spying that was not in dispute. As soon as some aspect of the program was in dispute, it ceased being part of the TSP.

Doesn't mean they stopped doing it, of course. The administration did what it wanted. It didn't have a name for anything that was not TSP. There was just TSP and non-TSP. What was TSP was whatever they wanted or needed to be TSP. Everything else was a program apart.

Awesome.

The key, of course, is to wrap the TSP's definition, the width and breadth of the spying, in a cloak of secrecy. Then you can sow confusion, appear to be lying, and have this elegant deception to explain it all away.

Now, if I just had Chuck Schumer's home phone. Not to explain the deception to him -- but to impress upon him the artistry of it.

Labels:

0 comments

Thursday, July 26, 2007

Alberto Gonzales: Not the TSP

Posted by: Hammer / 8:23 AM

Alberto Gonzales, Tuesday in a colloquy with Sen. Schumer:

"Not the TSP?" responded Sen. Charles E. Schumer, D-N.Y. "Come on. If you say it's about other, that implies not. Now say it or not."

"It was not," Gonzales answered. "It was about other intelligence activities."

From the AP, today:

A four-page memo from the national intelligence director's office shows that the White House briefing with the eight lawmakers on March 10, 2004, was about the terror surveillance program, or TSP.

The memo, dated May 17, 2006, and addressed to then-House Speaker Dennis Hastert, details "the classification of the dates, locations, and names of members of Congress who attended briefings on the Terrorist Surveillance Program," wrote then-Director of National Intelligence John Negroponte.

It shows that the briefing in March 2004 was attended by the Republican and Democratic House and Senate leaders and top Intelligence Committee members, as Gonzales testified.

It's too early to call Gonzales a liar -- but this contradiction will be awfully difficult to explain away.

Labels:

1 comments

Wednesday, July 25, 2007

Credibility of a witness is the domain of the jury

Posted by: Hammer / 8:34 AM

Josh Marshall points out an important exchange between Sen. Charles Schumer (D-NY) and Attorney General Alberto Gonzales. Schumer asks, repeatedly, whether the President sent Gonzales to John Ashcroft's sick bed in an attempt to get him to reverse the decision of the then-acting attorney general James Comey. Gonzales refuses to answer the question, except to say that he visited Ashcroft "on behalf" of the President:

In this exchange Sen. Schumer (D) asks Gonzales who sent him and Andy Card to John Ashcroft's bedside. And Gonzales just refuses to answer. He keep repeating that they went "on behalf" of the president. But he won't say if the president sent them. He just won't answer.

Schumer notes the key point: Gonzales isn't even asserting any kind of privilege. He doesn't say he can't remember. He just won't answer.

Marshall goes on to compare the testimony to a trial:

Testifying before Congress is like being called to testify in court. You have to answer every question. Every question. You can fudge and say you don't remember something and see how far you get. Or you can invoke various privileges. And it up to the courts to decide if the invocations are valid. But it's simply not permitted to refuse to answer the question. It is quite literally contempt of Congress.

I don't know if Marshall is correct here. By which I simply mean I am ignorant of the way this testimony works.

I have a guess, though, as to how this would actually play out in front of a jury. The witness refuses to answer a question and does not assert a right to not answer. The attorney would repeat the question. Next, you could ask the judge to direct the witness to answer the question.

But I think it stops there. I doubt that most judges would throw a witness into jail for contempt for responding to a question with a non-answer. If nothing else, it interferes with the flow and resolution of the trial. More likely, the judge would instruct the jury about the inferences they were permitted to draw from the witness's refusal to answer the question.

This highlights the way in which the Senate's hands are tied. The Senate could stop its proceedings and seek to hold Gonzales in contempt. This will result in a showdown over executive privilege which would last weeks, months, or years. Notably, the Senate's investigations into potential misconduct would be stymied. Worse, this exchange is of no consequence in the court of public opinion. Viewers might turn against Gonzales in droves, but the opinion of the American people matters not in this case. It's a jury of 1. He sits in the Oval Office. I suspect he's pleased.

Labels:

0 comments

Friday, April 27, 2007

Kyle Sampson's resignation

Posted by: Hammer / 8:30 AM

Yet another thought on Alberto Gonzales as manager. In early December, Kyle Sampson offered an explicit plan to deceive the U.S. Senate about the appointment of Tim Griffin. That plan was suggested in mid December. Sampson's email is dated December 19, 2006, but the plan did not reach Gonzales immediately.

Sampson's plan was to try to convince the Senate to accept Tim Griffin's appointment. If the Senate would not confirm mislead the Senate. To feign "good faith" and "gum [the process] to death".

Sampson was advising Gonzales to mislead the Senate. Shouldn't Sampson have been fired that day? Why did Gonzales wait for the shit to hit the fan 3 months later before showing Sampson the door?

Labels: ,

0 comments

Tuesday, March 27, 2007

Self-incrmination: Monica Goodling

Posted by: Hammer / 7:43 AM

Look, if Monica Goodling is afraid her candid testimony will expose her to criminal prosecution, there are options. For those who missed it, her justification is here:

Attorney General Alberto R. Gonzales's senior counselor yesterday refused to testify in the Senate about her involvement in the firings of eight U.S. attorneys, invoking her Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination.

Monica M. Goodling, who has taken an indefinite leave of absence, said in a sworn affidavit to the Senate Judiciary Committee that she will "decline to answer any and all questions" about the firings because she faces "a perilous environment in which to testify."

Perilous environments don't automatically trigger the right against self-incrimination. Frankly, the mere idea that a senior adviser to Alberto Gonzales is expressing concern that she committed a crime helps the investigation, at least temporarily.

It is possible to compel Goodling to testify by granting her immunity from prosecution based on her statements. Congress can't prosecute crimes -- it can only muck prosecutions up. See, e.g., Iran Contra.

Congress should not be deciding whether Goodling's testimony is worth immunity. That sounds like a job for a special prosecutor. You've got a senior adviser in the Department of Justice claiming that she can't testify because she might incriminate herself. Congress isn't designed to prosecute crimes. The DoJ obviously isn't the best choice to investigate itself. That only leaves an independent prosecutor to look into the matter.

I hear that Patrick Fitzgerald might be available.

Labels: ,

0 comments

Monday, March 26, 2007

One reason for Gonzales to stay

Posted by: Hammer / 8:27 AM

Hope you'll allow me to vacillate on a possible Gonzales resignation. Gonzales can't resign over his involvement in the firing of U.S. Attorneys for political reasons. It sets a precedent that anyone involved should resign. We know the White House was involved in the decisions, but we don't know how high up the decisions reached within the White House. Gonzales can't go, because that would mean Rove should go, too, and who knows how many others?

Bush has to stand by Gonzales to the end, because a crack in that wall will endanger the deepest realms of the White House.

Labels: , ,

0 comments

Blogroll

Special Feeds

Fun with Google

Search Tools

Technorati

Google

3WN WWW

Prior posts

  • Gar. Colbert stole the joke
  • May 15
  • I just like taking shots at religious extremists
  • Some people are tired of the Red state/Blue state ...
  • Palin's plans
  • Electoral bias
  • Norm Coleman: Civics Lesson Fail
  • Strange bedfellows
  • Billions for banks but not a penny for universal h...
  • Archives

    • Gone for now

    This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours? Site Meter Get Firefox!