spacer

Three Way News

Your Source. For everything. Really.

Contributors

Current Poll

Best comic strip?

  • Bloom County
  • Boondocks
  • Calvin and Hobbes
  • Dilbert
  • Doonesbury
  • Far Side
  • Foxtrot
  • Get Fuzzy
  • Life in Hell
  • Peanuts
  • Pearls Before Swine
  • Pogo
  • Zippy the Pinhead
  
Free polls from Pollhost.com

Recurring features

Hammer's Favorites

Jambo's Favories

Wednesday, August 01, 2007

Smilin' Norm Coleman -- Courage under Obfuscation

Posted by: Hammer / 7:55 AM

Sen. Norm Coleman has an op-ed piece in the Rochester Post-Bulletin. A taste:

On legislative matters, the Senate has a long history of filibustering. Even so, I have generally supported cloture votes when used to bring up a measure for debate and improvement on the Senate floor. For example, I've received some criticism for supporting cloture on a defense bill in 2005 that included a provision related to the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR), because I wanted to move the bill forward and take care of our troops. Ultimately, the ANWR provision was stripped from the bill and I was then able to support its final passage.

Unfortunately, since Sen. Reid took over as majority leader in January, he has filed cloture 46 times, compared to just 16 at the same point in 2005 or 11 at the same point in 2003 when Republicans were in control of the Senate. Nearly one in six roll-call votes taken in the Senate this year has been a cloture vote.

Darn that Harry Reid! Always trying to stifle debate. See, it's Harry Reid's fault for trying to cut off debate. You just can't blame Republicans for filibustering at a record pace.

I'm not an expert on the procedure of the Senate. My understanding is that the Senate traditionally governs debate through unanimous consent (PDF). The Senators agree on the parameters of the debate before the debate begins. Cloture For example, there was no cloture vote in the passage of the Pendsion Funding Equity Act of 2003:

Mr. McCONNELL. Mr. President, pursuant to the order previously agreed to, I ask unanimous consent that the Senate now proceed to the consideration of H.R. 3108, the pension bill.

The PRESIDING OFFICER. Without objection, it is so ordered.

Transcript.

In other words, absent unanimous consent, a bill cannot move forward without a cloture vote. One Republican senator is all it takes to require cloture. Blaming Harry Reid for following through on cloture votes is hypocrisy at its finest.

Fact is, the Republican senators have filibustered everything -- even the ethics reform package which recently passed the House again -- 411 to 8.

But at least one Republican Senator is threatening to filibuster ethics reform, as well. At the least we will see yet another vote on cloture, because Republican senators require it:

Those conservatives, led by Sens. Jim DeMint (R-South Carolina) and Tom Coburn (R-Oklahoma) are expected to block immediate consideration of the bill, and force a vote to end their filibuster, but after the lopsided House vote, Jim Manley, a spokesman for Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid(D-Nevada), asked, "Isn't it legitimate to ask the Republicans how they really want to proceed?"

Labels: ,

1 comments

Tuesday, July 24, 2007

The Circle is Complete: Smilin' Norm on the Filibuster

Posted by: Hammer / 7:40 AM

Smilin' Norm Coleman on the filibuster yesterday with Hannity and Colmes:

COLEMAN: Listen, I don't argue, by the way, about the 60-vote rule. On issues of importance, you've got to get 60 votes. What happened here on the floor of the Senate two nights ago, in the same night where they shot down the opportunity to provide protection for citizens who simply do what they should do, which is report behavior that they're concerned about, the vote was 49-48 to make sure we don't have a Fairness Doctrine. Evan Bayh was the only Democrat who voted with me.

So Democrats had a chance to express themselves on this issue. I don't argue with getting to 60; that's the way the Senate works. But, clearly, for some reason, Democrats wouldn't step forth and say, "Hey, we should put an end even worrying about whether there's a Fairness Doctrine."

Norm Coleman press release, December 21st, 2005:

I came to the Senate to get things done. I have never supported a filibuster, no matter how controversial the issue. Our troops, the victims of the hurricanes, and the families who depend on LIHEAP assistance deserved an up-or-down vote on the Senate floor today. Yet the outcome of this vote reveals a deep dissatisfaction among my colleagues. I am angry about the process and at the direction we have forced on these very important issues that now remain unresolved. We will now have to start over from square one. My only hope is that we bring back to the table a bill that excludes ANWR and will offer real choices to our troops and families and sets politics aside to get necessary legislation passed.

Labels: ,

0 comments

Thursday, June 28, 2007

Smilin' Norm Coleman: Maybe filibuster!

Posted by: Hammer / 8:33 AM

Just to complete the circle, here's Smilin' Norm's spokes-bot on whether Coleman will vote to filibuster the immigration bill:

When asked for the senator's criteria on whether he'll vote for cloture, a spokesman for Sen. Norm Coleman (R-Minn), explains, "His amendment will be a factor, the Graham amendment will be a factor as well as others on border security and workplace enforcement mechanisms. The question will be, “have we strengthened the bill enough?” If we can’t do that, he’s going to vote to kill this.”

The factor that's missing? Smilin' Norm's commitment to seeing that legislation gets the up-or-down vote it deserves.

As Ba Ha Ha noted in comments to a previous post, there's nothing wrong with Smilin' Norm threatening to filibuster a bill he doesn't like. He's trying to shape the bill to better suit his needs. He ought to do that. What's wrong is that when Republicans controlled the Senate, Smilin' Norm was opposed to the filibuster on principle, because legislation deserved an up-or-down vote.

Speaking of hypocrisy...

Dear Mr. Coleman,

My friend Norman.

Years ago, in a lifetime far away, you did not oppose the legalization of marijuana. Years ago, in our dorm rooms at Hofstra University, you, me, Billy, your future brother-in-law, Ivan, Jonathan, Peter, Janet, Nancy and a wealth of other students smoked dope.

Sure, we had to tape the doors shut, burn incense and open the windows, but we got high, and yet we grew up okay, without the help of the Office of National Drug Control Policy's advice...

Damn. Even Norm's doobie brothers are turning on him. All because he blazed up then, but believes it'll turn you crazy now.

Labels: , ,

2 comments

Wednesday, June 27, 2007

Smilin' Norm Coleman: No Filibuster!

Posted by: Hammer / 7:42 AM

Fresh off voting to filibuster the Employee Free Choice Act, Smilin' Norm has now flip-flopped on his filibuster of immigration reform:

Republican Sen. Norm Coleman voted today to end debate on a stalled bill to legalize millions of unlawful immigrants.

Coleman switched his vote in exchange for a promise the Senate would consider his amendment to allow local law enforcement to question people about their immigration status and share information about unlawful immigrants with federal authorities.

I guess the whole "up or down" vote principle is out the window. Once again, Smilin' Norm's only principle is self-preservation.

Labels: , ,

2 comments

Wednesday, April 25, 2007

Smilin' Norm: Filibuster

Posted by: Hammer / 10:57 AM

I am not familiar with the votes mentioned in this letter to the editor. Has Smilin' Norm voted to filibuster?

U.S. Sen. Norm Coleman's word can no longer be trusted. Coleman has said time and again that every bill deserves an up-or-down vote and that he will never support a filibuster.

In fact, he did not support the filibuster against drilling for oil in Alaska last year, even though he has always said he is against drilling for oil in Alaska.

Last week, Coleman voted two times on the Senate Intelligence Budget bill 372. On both of these votes, Coleman supported the filibuster.

Actually, Coleman managed to vote every which way possible on ANWR in the span of 24 hours. And to trumpet every vote he made with a press release.

Coleman did vote against cloture on the Intelligence Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2007 on April 17. Twice.

And I find this out hours after praising Coleman for being consistent in his opposition to the filibuster.

Labels: ,

0 comments

Blogroll

Special Feeds

Fun with Google

Search Tools

Technorati

Google

3WN WWW

Prior posts

  • Gar. Colbert stole the joke
  • May 15
  • I just like taking shots at religious extremists
  • Some people are tired of the Red state/Blue state ...
  • Palin's plans
  • Electoral bias
  • Norm Coleman: Civics Lesson Fail
  • Strange bedfellows
  • Billions for banks but not a penny for universal h...
  • Archives

    • Gone for now

    This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours? Site Meter Get Firefox!