spacer

Three Way News

Your Source. For everything. Really.

Contributors

Current Poll

Best comic strip?

  • Bloom County
  • Boondocks
  • Calvin and Hobbes
  • Dilbert
  • Doonesbury
  • Far Side
  • Foxtrot
  • Get Fuzzy
  • Life in Hell
  • Peanuts
  • Pearls Before Swine
  • Pogo
  • Zippy the Pinhead
  
Free polls from Pollhost.com

Recurring features

Hammer's Favorites

Jambo's Favories

Tuesday, October 30, 2007

Doesn't David Brooks read 3WN?

Posted by: Jambo / 8:49 AM

He must not:

don’t expect people to cast votes according to their income. Democrats do as well among top earners as Republicans.

One need only scroll down this page to see that's untrue. Now of course I don't expect him to read anything I write. Heck, my wife and most friends don't, so why should he be any different? But couldn't he at least read what his colleague Paul Krugman wrote just a couple days ago, which is where I got the charts to begin with? Can I expect to see a retraction in his next column?

Labels: , ,

1 comments

Sunday, October 28, 2007

Voting and income

Posted by: Jambo / 1:29 AM

Apparently a bunch of right wing commentators have lately been pushing the line that rich people vote Democrat. This is no doubt a part of their project to project their chosen image of liberals being some sort of distant elite whereas Republicans are friends of the common man. Not surprisingly it's a load of crap as these graphs, provided by some folks at Columbia University show. The results are for the 2004 presidential election and show how the electoral map would have looked if only voters in three different income segments had voted.

It's easy to see why Republicans try to suppress the votes of low income citizens. Republican policies tend to favor the rich. Democratic policies, not so much. And people generally vote accordingly. None of this should come as a surprise to anyone in the reality based community but as George Orwell said, "We have now sunk to a depth where the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men."

Labels: , , ,

3 comments

Tuesday, February 20, 2007

What about the middle class?

Posted by: Jambo / 10:07 PM

An interesting discussion about what, if anything, to do for the middle class:

There are five ways you could talk about the middle class in the current economy:

1. You could argue that the middle class faces serious economic stresses and anxieties, and government should help them deal with those things. That's kind of the position Senator Schumer has taken with his book Positively American, and with it, he's embraced some of the same policies, such as making college tuition deductible. I disagree with Schumer about his approach, but at least his solution fits his diagnosis of the problem.

2. You could argue that both the middle class and the working poor face increasing stresses, anxieties and insecurities, and there's a need for either universal programs that address that shared experience of insecurity (universal health care, wage insurance) or fundamental macroeconomic changes that would lead to a tighter labor market. That's more or less the position represented by, say, the Economic Policy Institute's "Shared Prosperity" project.

3. You could argue that the middle class is doing okay, but those below the median income – not just the poor, but those hanging on the precipice of the middle class and trying to climb up – are having a hard time of it, and we need policies that help their mobility, out of a moral obligation and out of our vision of America as a land of opportunity. This would be more or less John Edwards' "Two Americas" of 2004. (And not totally incompatible with option 2.)

4. You could argue that the middle class is doing fine, and therefore we should just keep doing what we've been doing, keep taxes and regulations low and let people "keep more of what they earn." This is Republican orthodoxy at the moment.

5. You could argue that the middle class is doing just fine, but we Democrats should throw a bunch of expensive tax credits and other benefits their way anyway because maybe they'll like us and vote for us.

The discussion started over a few articles trumpeting the fact that the middle class these days is actually doing quite well, in spite of what "pessimists" say. One of the facts they point to as proof is that "in 1979, only 12% of "prime-age households" (that is, singles or couples age 25-59) earned more than $100,000, today, 24% of such households have crossed the $100,000 line". It's not clear to me if they are talking about inflation adjusted incomes but even if they are I think they are missing (maybe intentionally) part of the problem by using the term "household". In 1979 I was 15 years old and like every kid I knew my mother didn't work. I don't think any of us even knew the concept of daycare. Our household income was my dad's. He was a career Navy officer and did pretty well. He was well short of $100k but we were comfortably middle class. Today my wife and I both work and are also comfortably middle class but with day care costs (at least before my kids started school) of around $20k a year. We are pretty much in the same social position as may family was in 1972 but now it takes two incomes to do it and a good part of the time our children are being raised by people other than us. I'm guessing the story is the same all over the country. There are several other facets to the argument and I'm not complaining (much) about my lot in life, but I think it's a mistake to pretend there haven't been some major changes in the last 30 years (for good and ill) that have a bearing on just how well off the middle class really is today.

Labels: ,

1 comments

Blogroll

Special Feeds

Fun with Google

Search Tools

Technorati

Google

3WN WWW

Prior posts

  • Gar. Colbert stole the joke
  • May 15
  • I just like taking shots at religious extremists
  • Some people are tired of the Red state/Blue state ...
  • Palin's plans
  • Electoral bias
  • Norm Coleman: Civics Lesson Fail
  • Strange bedfellows
  • Billions for banks but not a penny for universal h...
  • Archives

    • Gone for now

    This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours? Site Meter Get Firefox!