Friday, April 08, 2005
Zogby polls Schiavo
Posted by:
Hammer / 12:01 PM
Several polls showed that the American people opposed having Tom DeLay make end-of-life decisions for them. Now comes John Zogby with a poll for the
Christian Defense Coalition with different numbers:
A poll completed after the controversial death of Terri Schiavo finds that eight-in-ten (80%) likely voters say that a disabled person who is not terminally ill or in a coma, and not being kept alive by life support should not, in the absence of a written directive to the contrary, be denied food and water. By a three-to-one (44% to 14%) margin, likely voters say that, when there is conflicting evidence on the wishes of a patient, elected officials should order that a feeding tube remain in place. The survey, conducted by Zogby International on behalf of the Christian Defense Coalition, was conducted March 30 to April 2, 2005 and has a margin of error of +/-3.2 percentage points.
Sadly, Zogby's polling has not been particularly accurate
lately. I think, though, that this might have been the most misleading question in the history of polling:
Should a disabled person who is not terminally ill or in a coma, and not being kept alive by life support, be denied food and water? (My paraphrase, exact wording is not given the poll)
The fact that only 80% of Americans said "No" scares the heck out of me. My mother had a stroke on Thanksgiving. She still needs help walking; enough help, in fact, that she is, by any standard, "disabled". She is not terminally ill. She is not in a coma. She is not being kept alive by life support. Should she be denied food and water? Obviously not! (Except that, given her penchant for sweets, she needs to be denied some food so that her teeth don't rot out before she's able to pick up her grandkids again).
What the question leaves out, of course, is the central medical fact that Terri Schiavo was in a persistent vegetative state. Maybe it's wrong-headed, but most people perceive a qualitative difference between a disability and a persistent vegetative state.