
This is just unconscionable. A young woman in Iraq is gang raped by her fellow Halliburton/KBR contractors and then locked in a storage container so she won't talk. A US congressman intervenes to get her released but there are no criminal charges possible because, well, I guess contractors are a law unto themselves. But at least she can bring a civil suit back home, right?
Since no criminal charges have been filed, the only other option, according to Hutson, is the civil system, which is the approach that Jones is trying now. But Jones' former employer doesn't want this case to see the inside of a civil courtroom. KBR has moved for Jones' claim to be heard in private arbitration [where there will be no public record], instead of a public courtroom. It says her employment contract requires it.
So, no jury trial for you, missy. There may be a legitimate reason for contractor criminal immunity (I don't think there is but at least an argument can be made) but the arbitration agreement is just plain old corporate ass covering and it stinks. Yeah, we're not as bad as Saudi Arabia where you can get publicly whipped for the crime of being raped, but as the old saying goes, it's not that we're the same, it's that we're not different enough.
1 commentsChristopher Hitchens is the most mixed of mixed bags. His writings can draw from me anything from "right on" to "fuck you." This one is a winner. As he says part way through, if you have tears prepare to shed them. Nothing is ever really simple but I can still only blame one man and we all know who that is.
Labels: Iraq
1 commentsKevin Drum made the same point today about a couple other bills (he's got a cool chart, too) but it is just as true with this one:
Democrats Fall Short in Effort to Shift Course of Iraq War
A proposal that Democrats put forward as their best chance of changing the course of the Iraq war died on the Senate floor today, dealing the latest defeat to opponents of the war as Republicans stood firmly behind President Bush.
...Supporters of Mr. Bush’s war strategy declared victory, saying they had firmly beaten back legislative efforts to change course.
This sort of inaccurate reporting makes me crazy. The way it is worded makes it sound like the Democrats can't get a majority to support their bills which is patently untrue. The were 56 votes in favor and the only reason it didn't pass is because a minority of Republicans filibustered. But it is not until the 7th paragraph that we even find out that is what happened. An honest headline would read "Senate Republicans Filibuster Troop Withdrawal Plan." That would show which party is pushing a minority view and thwarting not just the majority of the senate but of the public as well. Liberal press my ass.
Labels: Iraq, liberal press my ass, media
0 commentsPresident Bush addresses a skeptical nation tonight. I don't know if he was planning to tout the draft oil revenue agreement, but I assume that's off the table now. Not just because the agreement fell apart in the last 24 hours, but because one of Bush's own guys might have helped bring it down:
The Shia and Sunni leaders believe the Kurds are opting for a sort of oil secession that puts them outside the whole concept of a law to share the country's oil resources. And the Hunt [Oil] deal is apparently the straw that broke the camel's back, shall we say. But remember, [Ray L.] Hunt ... is also a pal of the president's. Indeed, President Bush has twice appointed Hunt to his Foreign Intelligence Advisory Board. So while the president is striving to get the Iraqis to meet these benchmarks one of his own pals -- and more importantly, political appointees -- is busy helping to tear the whole thing apart.
Labels: Bush, Iraq, oil revenues, Ray Hunt
1 commentsThis is the sort of thing that just makes me want to pull my hair out. From a poll taken just last week:
"Do you think Saddam Hussein was personally involved in the September 11th, 2001, terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon?"
all adults, 33% said yes
Republicans, 40% said yes
Democrats, 27% said yes
independents, 32% said yes
Gaaaaa!!! How, HOW, can we expect rational policy and meaningful elections when such a large segment of the population is so grossly ill-informed? I don't know which worries me more, that 4 out of 10 Republicans thought so or that even a quarter of Democrats did. I'd love to see the breakdown on answers vs. where people get their their news. We're doomed.
Labels: Iraq, terrorism, voters
3 commentsIn addition to the build-up of American ground forces in Iraq, the Bush "surge" included political pressure to promote reconciliation. A reminder from Juan Cole on how that's going:
Iraq's parliament went on a one-month hiatus Tuesday afternoon, having not passed any significant legislation. Bush had outlined 4 'benchmarks' last January that the Iraqi government needed to meet by June. There were passage of a petroleum law, passage of a law specifying distribution of the petroleum revenues, revisions of debaathification rules [which harm Sunni Arabs], and progress on Sunni-Shiite reconciliation. Nothing has been accomplished on any of these fronts.
Labels: Iraq, reconciliation, surge
0 commentsSaw this quote from Hillary Clinton on withdrawal of troops from Iraq:
Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton said the Pentagon is not even planning how to do it, but her best estimate is that one brigade or two a month can be withdrawn.
“Yes we want to begin moving the troops out, but we want to do it safely and orderly and carefully,’’ she said.
That's just bullshit. Surely if we can land some 130,000 troops in a single day under direct fire from entrenched positions, we could withdraw more than a couple thousand troops in a month. Put another way, if we have roughly 160,000 troops in Iraq now and could withdraw only 6,000 troops a month, it would take two full years to withdraw all American forces from Iraq. The insertion of those troops took but a few months.
While it would be both impossible and unwise to withdraw all American forces from Iraq in the span of 24 hours, we certainly could remove all forces in a matter of weeks, not years, should we choose to.
Labels: Hillary Clinton, Iraq
0 commentsOh, those pernicious Brits. At least the plague of man-eating badgers will prepare Iraqis for the coming zombie apocalypse:
British forces have denied rumours that they released a plague of ferocious badgers into the Iraqi city of Basra.
Word spread among the populace that UK troops had introduced strange man-eating, bear-like beasts into the area to sow panic.
But several of the creatures, caught and killed by local farmers, have been identified by experts as honey badgers.
The rumours spread because the animals had appeared near the British base at Basra airport.
UK military spokesman Major Mike Shearer said: "We can categorically state that we have not released man-eating badgers into the area.
Labels: Iraq, man-eating badgers
1 commentsThe Iraqi government has failed to meet any of its targets for reform. President Bush is to inform Congress of this unhappy news this week.
Surge or no surge, the only solution in Iraq is political. Theory was that a surge in combat forces would reduce violence enough to give the political process time enough and air enough to move toward conciliation. (Theory also was that the surge was going to temporarily increase violence, but the surge policy like a Monet print does not withstand close scrutiny.)
How long should American soldiers die for a government that refuses to take any action at all?
Labels: Iraq
0 commentsYou know, if you tried this in a work of fiction someone would call shenanigans. But the Rude Pundit has the story of how the wife of one of the most recent missing soldiers in Iraq is about to get deported for being in the U.S. illegally. She was caught, wait for it, because her husband, before he went missing, tried to get her a Green Card.
Labels: immigration, Iraq
0 commentsThis doesn't sound very reassuring:
Friends of his from Texas were shocked recently to find him nearly wild-eyed, thumping himself on the chest three times while he repeated "I am the president!" He also made it clear he was setting Iraq up so his successor could not get out of "our country's destiny."
Well he has sure set up Iraq for something, all right.
0 commentsYou know that we liberals hate America and want the terrorists to win (really, just ask the Republicans, they'll tell you) so it's not surprising that I forgot to do any sort of Memorial Day post. Had I done one it would have featured this sadly beautiful song by the Drive-by Truckers:
It's not an anti-war song. It's just an anti-young-person-dying-too-soon song and it's as moving as any pop song on the subject is ever likely to be.
"Dress Blues"
What can you see from your window
I can't see anything from mine
Flags on the side of the highway
Scripture on grocery store signs
Maybe 18 was too early
Maybe 30 or 40 is too
Did you get chance to make peace with the man
Before he sent down his angels for you?
Mama's and grandmama's love you
Cause that's all they know how to do
And you never planned on the bombs in the sand
Or sleeping in your dress blues
[I don't know if it has been released on an album yet (it hadn't been when I first tried to find it) but if any of you would like a decent copy of it drop me an email and I'll send you a pretty good mp3 that that I recorded from a radio steam of an in studio performance.]
0 commentsLooks like giving an honorary degree to Iraq war salesman Andrew Card was not such a popular idea at UMass.
It sure would be nice if just once W had to face a crowd like that.
Labels: Iraq
0 commentsOne of the mounting costs of Bush's failed war policy:
0 commentsThe bitter fight over the latest Iraq spending bill has all but obscured a sobering fact: The war will soon cost more than $500 billion.
That's about ten times more than the Bush administration anticipated before the war started four years ago, and no one can predict how high the tab will go. The $124 billion spending bill that President Bush plans to veto this week includes about $78 billion for Iraq, with the rest earmarked for the war in Afghanistan, veterans' health care and other government programs.
Hardliners in the Bush administration (hey, talking about W sounds more like talking about the old Soviet Union everyday!) have an effective sound bite when they say Democrats are "voting for defeat" in Iraq. It's a lie, of course, but that doesn't mean it doesn't help them. Democrats are always pretty lame in the soundbite department and I wish they would come up with a good counter for for this latest propaganda. Here's my suggestion: Every time the Republicans trot out this lie Democrats should counter with the claim that Bush doesn't want to win the war, he just wants to delay withdrawal until he's out of office. Every additional soldier who dies does so only so Bush can save face. OK, it's two lines long which is one more than a real soundbite is supposed to have but I still think it can work if we repeat it often enough. It even has the benefit of most likely being true. Joe Biden made this point months ago but no one really followed up on it. But the secret to this sort of thing is repetition. Have enough different people in enough different forums saying this and we can really leverage the public's already healthy distrust of W to increase the pressure to end the war, or at least our involvement in it.
1 commentsI know that simply referring to the nation's leader as a petulant asshole is in no way an insightful commentary and does nothing to advance any cause I might favor but is there any other way to react to the man these days?
Speaking somberly on the South Lawn of the White House before leaving on a trip to New York, Bush said he was willing to meet with Democratic leaders "as many times as it takes to resolve our differences," but he signaled no intention to compromise with them on the funding bill for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
So "resolve our differences" means do just what the president wants. Is there any reason to talk to, or even listen to, this man any more? And I don't mean that rhetorically, either. Would anything be made worse if Democrats announced that the president was no longer someone capable of engaging in honest, or even competent, dialog and simply refused to meet with him? Best of all would be having the mainstream press decide there was no longer any reason to cover someone so vacuous and dishonest. Best case scenario has him hitting the bottle again out of frustration that no one even pretends he matters any more. Double plus good best case has him suffering a breakdown and put on 24 hour suicide watch for his remaining days in office. After that let Laura look after him and I don't give a shit what happens to him.
4 commentsHere's a new definition of "always" coming out of Iraq, where at least 160 more people were killed:
At least 160 people have been killed in four major bomb blasts around Baghdad today - the bloodiest violence since a US troop "surge" and crackdown on insurgents began in February.
..."We've seen both inspiring progress, and too much evidence that we still face many grave challenges," the US military spokesman Major General William Caldwell told reporters today. "We've always said securing Baghdad would not be easy."
Before the war, nothing was said about securing Baghdad. The invasion, we were told, would be a marked by more injuries from falling rose petals than enemy action. I think it's utterly fair to hold the administration responsible for the implied claim that American involvement in Iraq would be very short.
Some, out of a surplus of fairness, note that the administration was largely silent on the aftermath of the invasion. There are no direct statements from the architects of this war proclaiming that the occupation of Iraq would be easy.
Contrariwise, there are no pre-war proclamations that the occupation would be difficult. Until now, when General Caldwell helpfully explains that we've always been told that securing Baghdad would not be easy.
I call bullshit on the always. This war was sold in a whitewash and there's no use pretending otherwise. That we've seen a limited amount of facing reality since our Mission was Accomplished is no great comfort.
Labels: Iraq
0 commentsRobert Parry takes a look at timetables in Iraq:
It has become a standard part of George W. Bush’s litany for why he will veto a congressional plan for setting a timetable for withdrawing U.S. combat forces from Iraq: “Why would you say to the enemy, ‘Here’s a timetable. Just go ahead and wait us out?’”
Well, there’s a logical answer to Bush’s rhetorical question. If a timetable encourages Iraqi insurgents to silence their guns and to stop planting roadside bombs – even temporarily to wait the Americans out – Iraq might get the breathing space it needs to begin healing its sectarian divisions.
Indeed, one could argue that Bush’s “surge” plan and Bush’s fear about letting the enemy “wait us out” offer essentially the same opportunity: to achieve enough peace and quiet in the short term for reconciliation and reconstruction to begin.
That's my thinking exactly. The best argument for a timetable is, the reason Bush uses to argue against a timetable.
Clearly, there's more at work here. Take a look at McCain's latest speech on Iraq:
America has a vital interest in preventing the emergence of Iraq as a Wild West for terrorists, similar to Afghanistan before 9/11. By leaving Iraq before there is a stable Iraqi governing authority we risk precisely this, and the potential consequence of allowing terrorists sanctuary in Iraq is another 9/11 or worse. In Iraq today, terrorists have resorted to levels of barbarism that shock the world, and we should not be so naive as to believe their intentions are limited solely to the borders of that country. We Americans are their primary enemy, and we Americans are their ultimate target.
A power vacuum in Iraq would invite further interference from Iran at a time when Tehran already feels emboldened enough to develop nuclear weapons, threaten Israel and America, and kidnap British sailors. If the government collapses in Iraq, which it surely will if we leave prematurely, Iraq's neighbors, from Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Syria, Turkey and Egypt, will feel pressure to intervene on the side of their favored factions. This uncertain swirl of events could cause the region to explode and foreclose the opportunity for millions of Muslims and their children to achieve freedom. We could face a terrible choice: watch the region burn, the price of oil escalate dramatically and our economy decline, watch the terrorists establish new base camps or send American troops back to Iraq, with the odds against our success much worse than they are today.
I don't think McCain's got it right, either. Iraq is not Afghanistan. Afghanistan featured a strong, geographically limited government. The Taliban's rule did not stretch to the borders of the country, but it did provide resources and support to terrorists within its sphere of influence. The Afghani model, then, includes a functioning government supporting terrorists. The McCain forecast for Iraq is a collapsed state. This is a striking difference.
McCain argues that Americans are the ultimate target for Muslim extremists. I think he's incorrect. Sunni extremists such as those in al Qaeda view Shiites as the primary enemy. I'm willing to be educated on this point, but I do believe the senator misunderstands the stated objectives of al Qaeda.
The Sunnis clearly do not want us in Iraq (though they should). Thousands -- perhaps millions -- of Shia want us out of Iraq, as well. The increasingly irrelevant minority that wants the U.S. to stay in Iraq continues to lose credibility and support. If there comes a time when no Iraqis want American forces in Iraq, will we stay even then?
Labels: Iraq, John McCain
0 commentsThousands of Shia are protesting the American presence in Iraq. According to some reports there are hundreds of thousands of protesters:
Hundreds of thousands of supporters of the radical Shia cleric Moqtada al-Sadr took to the streets of two Shia holy cities in Iraq today and protested against "US occupiers".
The rally was called by Mr Sadr, who said in a statement yesterday that his militia followers should redouble efforts to drive US forces out of Iraq, describing them as "your arch-enemy".
...Today some Iraqi soldiers in uniform joined the crowd, which was led by at least a dozen turbaned clerics - including one Sunni.
Remind me again -- why are we there? What are we fighting for?
Labels: Iraq
0 commentsNo, Anna Nicole Smith was not shot in the back of the head. But the AP is reporting that Shia police officers in Tal Afar, in northwestern Iraq, participated in a day-long killing spree which left 60 Sunnis dead:
Shiite militants and police enraged by massive truck bombings in the northwestern town of Tal Afar went on a revenge spree against Sunni residents there Wednesday, killing as many as 60 people, officials said.
The gunmen began roaming Sunni neighborhoods in the city, shooting at residents and homes, according to police and a local Sunni politician.
Ali al-Talafari, a Sunni member of the local Turkomen Front Party, said the Iraqi army had arrested 18 policemen accused of being involved after they were identified by the Sunni families targeted. But he said the attackers included Shiite militiamen.
He said more than 60 Sunnis had been killed, but a senior hospital official in Tal Afar put the death toll at 45, with four wounded.
Labels: Iraq
0 comments