Wednesday, January 26, 2005
Heroes and lousy parents
Posted by:
Hammer / 11:10 AM
The Bull Moose
roars:
The Moose has been strongly critical of the Bushies' conduct of the war. However, he has also believed that we cannot allow Iraq to become a failed state in a region that is critical to our national interests. And even if one opposed the war, one can still admire, appreciate and support the efforts of Iraqis to achieve freedom.
A moving profile appears in the New York Times today of one such Iraqi,
"The doctor pulled a Czech pistol from his glove compartment on a recent day and walked into the mosque.
"His professional mission, he acknowledges, is to save lives, to treat the weak and infirm.
But Dr. Riyadh N. al-Adhadh, a Sunni Arab, is also running for a Baghdad provincial council seat in the elections on Sunday.
"I've had this for one year, but only in the last two weeks have I started carrying it," the doctor said as he handed the pistol to a reporter. "I know it's useless. If they want to kill me, they will."
Dr. al-Adhadh is clearly brave. I wondered, though, if he had children. Informed, as Hammer has been, by Kurt Vonnegut's
Fates Worse Than Death, pages
141-:
"I don't believe that we are about to be crucified. No potential enemy we now face has anywhere near enough carpenters. Not even people at the Pentagon at budget time have mentioned crucifixion. I am sorry to have put that idea into their heads. ...
"But what if they said, instead, that we would be enslaved if we did not appropriate enough money for weaponry...And slavery would surely be a fate worse than death...."
"So Americans and Russians can both stand slavery, if they have to -- and still want life to go on and on."
"Could it be that slavery isn't a fate worse than death? After all, people are tough. Maybe we shouldn't send that message to the Pentagon -- about slavery and Kool-Aid time."
"But suppose enemies came ashore in great numbers...and they push us out of our homes and off our ancestral lands...Suppose that they even tried to destroy our religion..."
"Again: this is a wringer millions of Americans have already been through...It is another catastrophe Americans can endure, if they have to -- still, miraculously, maintaining some measure of dignity, of self-respect."
"As bad as life is for our Indians, they still like it better than death."
"So I haven't had much luck, have I, in identifying fates worse than death? Crucifixion is the only clear winner so far, and we aren't about to be crucified."
Vonnegut's point about the Kool-Aid is that we ought not prepare for nuclear war -- a war we should never engage in, because no fate awaits us that is worse that the death of all living things.
Back to Dr. Al-Adhadh.
Freedom demands heroes. Brave men and women to sacrifice their lives, if need be, for freedom. Liberty is wrenched from the hands of despots and petty tyrants. Liberty is not the natural state of mankind -- our natural state is disorder.
The story doesn't say whether Dr. Al-Adhadh has children. The story doesn't say whether his children would prefer to live in freedom as orphans or in slavery with their father.
Hammer wants to provide food and shelter and medical care for the Sisters Hammer. Hammer wants freedom for them, too, but would provide them nourishment before the right to vote.
Dr. Al-Adhadh is a brave man, risking his life to defend what he believes in. But is he a good father? Or does freedom demand that, as well -- the abandonment of your children to the world you leave them? That is, it seems, the fortunate case, because nothing -- not freedom, to be sure -- fills the emptiness when a child leaves a parent's world.
No answers here. Just a question to the wise.