Thursday, January 13, 2005
Social Security: To the New York Times, facts don't matter
Posted by:
Hammer / 1:01 PM
Bush Presses His Argument for Social Security Change:
President Bush stepped up his campaign on Tuesday to sell Americans and a skeptical Congress on the need to overhaul Social Security by painting a dire picture of a bankrupt future for millions of young workers.
"If you're 20 years old, in your mid-20's, and you're beginning to work, I want you to think about a Social Security system that will be flat bust, bankrupt, unless the United States Congress has got the willingness to act now," Mr. Bush said at an event that the White House billed as a "conversation on Social Security" with ordinary citizens. ...
Many Democrats and economists say that Mr. Bush is exaggerating the problem, and that Social Security could be fixed with modest tax increases and a cut in benefits. Even without changes, Mr. Bush's critics say, the system would be able to pay three-quarters of promised benefits four decades from now, when baby boomers have long retired.
Who are these unnamed critics? Left-wingers, communists, and worse; all of whom have managed to invade the
Congressional Budget Office and the Social Security Administration:
According to the trustees' intermediate economic forecast (neither doom nor boom), the trust fund will be able to pay about 73 percent of scheduled benefits in 2042 and about 68 percent of scheduled benefits in 2078.
For the highest earners, Social Security is currently promising $53,411 [2004 dollars] per year for those who retire in 2080 (or $36,319 per year if Social Security can pay only 68 percent). Current maximum benefits are $21,891 per year for those who retired last year.
In other words, under the intermediate scenario, according to SSA, if we do nothing now, folks who retire in 2080 will be paid a higher benefit -- in constant dollars -- than the current retirees. The
CBS Marketwatch article (registration required) does what the New York Times is afraid to do. It compares Bush's own words with known facts. The Times's reporter, Elisabeth Bumiller, has already made clear that she doesn't intend to argue with the president during
serious times.